Articles & Questions
Every week I publish a fun new article on a money topic I think you’ll find interesting. I also answer a handful of reader questions. Subscribers to my newsletter get to see everything first — but you can browse some of my past articles & questions on this page.
My Best Articles
Not sure where to start? Below I’ve handpicked a few of my favourites. And if you like what you see, don’t forget to subscribe to my free newsletter to get new issues before anyone else!
Search Articles
From the Depths of Despair
I sat in my GP’s office crying my heart out, feeling suffocated by my $27,000 debt, feeling depressed like there was no way out. My GP listened to every word I said (in between sobs) and finally said, “I think we need a longer appointment”, and asked me to come back the next day.
Hi Scott,
Not a question. I just want to say THANK YOU!
I know you receive hundreds of messages like this, probably each week if not each day, but I just wanted to share my experience of going Barefoot. At 31, having been married the year prior, I sat in my GP’s office crying my heart out, feeling suffocated by my $27,000 debt, feeling depressed like there was no way out. My GP listened to every word I said (in between sobs) and finally said, “I think we need a longer appointment”, and asked me to come back the next day.
Around that time a friend had suggested I read The Barefoot Investor. I had of course scoffed at the suggestion, but that day I decided I needed something, anything, to help. I read the book cover to cover in a day and felt so empowered that I began to draw my buckets and to have the conversation with my husband.
Two-and-a-half years on, I never did rebook that appointment! My husband and I are completely debt free! We own (outright) two cars, have had a baby, have been on a four-month holiday overseas, have saved $40,000, and are ready to buy our first home. Thank you, Scott. You will never know what your book did for our family.
Nikki
Hi Nikki
You bloody ripper!
In the sea of doom and gloom and depressing news, I’m craving good news stories, and hope — and that’s exactly what your story offers people.
You Got This!
Scott
We Hit the Jackpot!
This month, my husband and I will finally be debt free! We owe nothing (though we also own nothing). My hubby used to have an addiction to gambling and a $120,000 debt on credit cards.
Hi Scott,
This month, my husband and I will finally be debt free! We owe nothing (though we also own nothing). My hubby used to have an addiction to gambling and a $120,000 debt on credit cards. We have spent the past five years paying every last cent off, while having three children under five, and I’ve also been studying at uni. My question is: moving forward, how can we make the best decisions to create wealth, and is trading shares just a form of gambling?
Kylie
Hi Kylie,
What a truly amazing all-of-family feat.
The fact that you guys bunkered down and paid off all your debts tells me a lot about the people you really are.
Know this: done right, investing isn’t the same as gambling.
You’re saving so you can provide for your family’s long-term security.
That is the polar opposite of gambling.
My advice?
Invest — but do it via your boring-as-hell low-cost super fund. Do it via a regular, automatic direct debit. Never look at the balance. Only check it once a year when your statement comes in the post.
And keep repeating to yourself: I’m not gambling … I’m providing a better future for my family.
You Got This!
Scott
The Hangover
My daughter lives with her partner and three children in a property that I own. They have many bills and are unable to pay rent. Her partner is wasting his money on gambling and will not change…
Hi Scott,
My daughter lives with her partner and three children in a property that I own. They have many bills and are unable to pay rent. Her partner is wasting his money on gambling and will not change — he has even stated that he wants to keep his head in the sand. How do I get him to grow up? I have given him your book and my daughter is trying hard and has since started part-time work. However, they have three car loans and have debt collectors visiting frequently. Help! I feel powerless.
Jenny
Hi Jenny
It must be horrible to see your daughter go through this.
Now I know you’re coming at it from a place of love, but giving her partner my book won’t help one bit.
Why?
Because it sounds like he’s in the grips of a gambling addiction. And, if that’s the case, giving him my book is like giving an alcoholic a Panadol for a hangover.
So, what can you do?
A couple of things:
First, as hard as this sounds, drop the judgement.
I’ve learnt to view people with gambling addictions the same way I view anyone with a serious illness.
“When will you grow up?!” is like asking someone with a mental illness “When will you be happy?!”
Him telling you that he “wants to keep his head in the sand” sounds like a reaction to feeling judged.
Trust me, he knows how bad it is.
Second, encourage both him and your daughter to see a financial counsellor. Ideally, it would be a specialist gambling financial counsellor (call Gamblers Help on 1800 858 858 for a referral).
However, if he’s not ready to get help, encourage your daughter to go on her own. Reason being, the debt collectors will not let up, but a financial counsellor will sort them out and stop the calls.
Finally, you’re doing an amazing job providing them with a roof over their head. Make sure they keep getting the basics: food, power and schoolbooks.
You say you feel powerless. Just remember, that’s probably how your son-in-law feels too.
Scott
How to Honour Him
Hi Scott, I am in my early thirties and feel hopeless. Recently I lost my brother to a very long and hard battle with cancer, and in his will he left me $10,000. I was thinking about spending it on a holiday or a nice piece of jewellery to remember him by,
Hi Scott,
I am in my early thirties and feel hopeless. Recently I lost my brother to a very long and hard battle with cancer, and in his will he left me $10,000. I was thinking about spending it on a holiday or a nice piece of jewellery to remember him by, but I also have a $20,000 credit card debt that I have struggled to pay off for the past 10 years. Would you put it towards the debt or go on a nice holiday to get away from all the painful memories?
Bec
Hi Bec,
I’m sorry for your loss.
Here’s what I think: I think that losing your brother is a tragic, heartbreaking reminder that life is precious.
Bec, life is far too short to spend it being a slave to a bank.
And make no mistake: while you’re paying them $3,600 a year in interest, you’re effectively a financial slave.
If you keep on paying the minimum, it’ll take you 54 years to be free (and that’s if you stop spending on it today).
I think you should honour your brother, cut up your credit card right now, and live the rich life that he can’t.
Make him proud.
Scott
Terrified of Debt Collectors
Barefoot, I am a stay-at-home mum with three kids. When my hubby and I moved to Brissie a few years ago, we had barely any money, so we got a credit card (and he also had a personal loan from a previous relationship).
Barefoot,
I am a stay-at-home mum with three kids. When my hubby and I moved to Brissie a few years ago, we had barely any money, so we got a credit card (and he also had a personal loan from a previous relationship). We could not keep up the payments, so we went on a debt agreement, but we ended up cancelling it as we could not afford that either. Long story short, we are now around $60,000 in debt. We have been ignoring calls as we cannot afford payments, and I am terrified debt collectors will come knocking soon. Help!
Jolanda
Hi Jolanda,
Your situation sounds … utterly exhausting.
Here’s the truth: feeling terrified is not conducive to making good decisions.The debt industry knows this, and they feed this feeling, because it’s the best way to get more money out of you.
That’s why debt collection companies hound you multiple times a day.
That’s why payday lenders like (Crime Converters … er, I mean Cash Converters) bombard you with text messages on short-term loans.
And that’s how someone signed you up for an expensive magic wand known as a ‘Part 9 debt agreement’.
Often these debt agreements are sold to people as a way for them to avoid bankruptcy … when the truth is that they are in fact an act of bankruptcy. In other words, you paid this mob thousands of dollars (that you didn’t have) for something that didn’t work.So what’s the answer?
It’s time to stop the terror, Jolanda, and get back in control.
Rather than ignoring the calls, it’s time to make a call:
First thing tomorrow I want you to call the National Debt Helpline on 1800 007 007.
They’ll put you in contact with someone like me — a free, independent, not-for-profit financial counsellor.
We can stop the calls from debt collectors, banks and other creditors, and negotiate a payment on your behalf.
It’s time to get you back on your feet!
Scott
From $500 to $15,000
Scott I do not have a question, I just want to say thank you. Two years ago I walked out of an abusive relationship with $500 to my name and debts that should never have belonged to me.
Scott
I do not have a question, I just want to say thank you. Two years ago I walked out of an abusive relationship with $500 to my name and debts that should never have belonged to me. My sister and brother-in-law gave me your book and I quickly decided this was how I would take control again. After two years of hard work and sacrifice, I have paid off all my debts and saved almost $15,000, and I am hoping to buy my first home at the end of 2020. I keep all of your columns in a folder called “YOU CAN DO IT” — and I did!
Rachel
Hi Rachel,
I love celebrating the wins of the Barefoot community.
Yet I love it even more that right now, hundreds (if not thousands) of people in abusive relationships are reading your story and getting a little inspiration and motivation from hearing about someone who’s done it.
You Got This!
Scott
Hello, I’m calling on behalf of my idiot husband...
I picked up the phone at my financial counselling office. It was a woman, breathing very heavily: “I need to speak to a gambling counsellor.
I picked up the phone at my financial counselling office. It was a woman, breathing very heavily:
“I need to speak to a gambling counsellor.”
“Do you have a gambling problem?” I asked.
“No, it’s not for me. I’m not that stupid. It’s for my idiot husband.”
Turns out she’d just caught her husband of almost 20 years gambling on his phone.
He broke down in tears and admitted to her that he’d been gambling heavily for the past five years.
“How much has he lost?” I asked.
“Four thousand dollars”, she said bitterly.
“As in … total? That’s it!? Are you sure?” I asked, with both my eyebrows fully cocked.
“Yes, I am sure. I told him, “If you’re lying to me, I’ll cut your nuts off!”
Intense.
Then again, if my wife had threatened me with that, I’d have low-balled her too.
(Pardon the pun.)
Look, I have no doubt this poor woman was in shock and denial.
And I also have no doubt that her husband’s losses would rise as she put down her butcher’s knife.
Here’s a ballpark of what he may end up fessing up to, courtesy of Graham, a real-life case study from Financial Counselling Australia:
Graham thought he and his wife were tracking along nicely. His wife enjoyed the occasional ‘flutter’ on the weekend. Besides, she couldn’t do too much damage — she only earnt $672 a week.
Then he got flattened when she confessed to running up $130,000 in debt.
They may well lose their home.
You probably know that we Aussies are the biggest punters on the planet ... but you may not appreciate that the biggest losers are the families of gamblers.
And the winners?
There are three:
The gambling companies (obviously). The governments (tax revenue). And … the banks.
You see, credit cards used for gambling are a huge money spinner because gambling is a cash advance, which attracts a higher interest rate, charged from day one.
Last month Financial Counselling Australia called on the Australian Banking Association to follow the lead of the UK, which last month banned credit cards being used for gambling.
A handful of smaller Aussie banks have already done so, but none of the big four banks have yet ... though they say they’re “considering it”.
Thankfully, self-isolation has meant that with the casinos and pokie-dens closed, we’re no longer gambling.
Yeah right!
Aussie spending on online betting increased a massive 142% in the last week of April compared to a normal week, according to analytics group AlphaBeta.
My view?
It’s high time the big banks put their nuts on the line and banned credit cards being used for gambling.
Do it for Graham.
Do it for my ballsy client.
Do it for every kid who has a parent afflicted with this terrible disease.
Tread Your Own Path!
Nursing My Debt
Hi there, I know you are probably sick of hearing this … but thank you so much. Four months ago I picked up your book.
Hi there,
I know you are probably sick of hearing this … but thank you so much. Four months ago I picked up your book.I am a single dad who works as a nurse, owns his own home, and works three jobs to make ends meet. I was $3,000 in credit card debt, had $750 of my rates outstanding, and a measly but annoying $220 of my car insurance still to pay. Well, today I domino-ed the last of these debts as I paid off my credit card. I jumped around my bedroom listening to the song ‘Celebration’ by Kool & The Gang … I was so proud of myself!
Sam
Hey Sam,
How impressive are you?
You’re working three jobs -- including one of society's most important jobs -- just to get ahead for your kid.
In my book Barefoot Investor for Families, I encourage parents to do a family backyard ‘bill burning ceremony’ -- literally setting fire to a paid off bill, credit card or loan.
They’ll likely remember that night 30 years from now, and the underlying lesson: work hard and get out of debt.
Celebrate good times, come on! Thank-you for reading
Scott
Too Broke to Go Broke
Dear Scott, I am one of those ‘bastard bosses’ you talk about — I am still about $40,000 behind on my employees’ super (including mine — I have not paid myself any super, ever). I am also going broke.
Dear Scott,
I am one of those ‘bastard bosses’ you talk about — I am still about $40,000 behind on my employees’ super (including mine — I have not paid myself any super, ever). I am also going broke. After six years of trying everything to stay afloat, including selling all my personal assets, my company ceased trading at the end of last month.Now I am trying to work out what the hell to do from here. By the time I liquidate what’s left, there should be enough to pay out the employees’ super, but there will still be about $150,000 in debt, mostly to the ATO. I’ve been advised to hire a liquidator, to do things correctly and end up with more to pay to their super, but I have been told it will cost about $15,000. I know it’s all on me — but do you have any advice on what I should do next?
Simon
Hi Simon,
I don’t think you’re a bastard boss -- you gave it a go and you couldn’t make it work. Fact is, more than 1,000 small businesses go broke each week in Australia, according to data analysts Illion.
One option you have is to pay your employees their super, directly into their funds, with any money you have left.
As for the ATO, there are two ways to go: appoint your own (expensive) liquidator, or wait for the ATO to eventually appoint their own. And if it works out that you’re personally liable, then really your only option is to negotiate a settlement with the ATO, or declare bankruptcy. My take?
The person who told you to see a liquidator was bang on. If you don’t, there’s a risk that you’ll open yourself up to even more trouble. It’s time to let the nightmare play out.
Scott
Dead Broke in a Beamer
Christmas came early for my kids this year ...Daddy finally got a job.
Christmas came early for my kids this year ...
Daddy finally got a job.
(Well, to be accurate, 220 hours of community service as part of my Financial Counselling qualification.)
On my first day, the three of them surprised me by getting up really early and having a celebratory breakfast with me (possibly with the aim of making sure I really did have a job to go to).
And when I returned home that night I was greeted — for the first, and possibly last, time — like David Boon coming home with The Ashes.
“Didja have a lot of meetings, Dad?” asked my six-year-old, beaming with pride.
In the schoolyard, real dads go to work and have meetings. (Not bum around the farm in their trackie dacks.)
It doesn’t matter that he can see me on TV, hear me on the radio, and watch me do book signings with lines a hundred deep: when I’m wearing a tie, carrying a keep-cup and battling the morning traffic, I am THE MAN.
So now that I’m a couple of hundred hours into this job I’ve learned that it’s like being a (financial) E.R. doctor.
No one wants to be sitting in front of me.
They’re often embarrassed, humiliated, angry, scared ... and completely strung out about their finances.
My job is to sit them down, calm them down, and assess their situation.
It’s basically financial triage: you patch them up, stem the bleeding, and send them back out (where you can). Or, if you deem their situation terminal, you tell their creditors and cut deals on their debts.
(This of course sounds sexy but, trust me, if your life gets to the point where a bank is willing to write off your debts, you’ll be celebrating with spuds and spumante.)
Above all, what I’ve learned is that this job is relentless.
Debt in this country is an epidemic, and people of all shapes and sizes stream through the door.
Like a bloke in his 40s that I saw today.
He arrived to our appointment in a BMW X5.
“Why does this guy need to see me?” I thought to myself.
He sat down, threw his fancy keys on the table, and buried his face in his hands.
He confessed that he’d leased the car five years ago and now couldn’t afford the final balloon payment. (And if you don’t know what a balloon is — don’t feel bad — neither did he.)
The upshot was that he was broke, and the Beamer would soon be repossessed.
Yet you know what?
To the outside world he’s THE MAN. He’s got an awesome car that he drops his kids off to school in.
By the time he came to see me, it was too late for him to avoid his mistakes.
But it’s not too late for his kids.
And what this financial tour of duty has taught me is just how much we need a financial revolution in our schools.
My client grew up thinking that success meant leasing a $100,000 Beamer … and he paid the price.
I want his kids to grow up knowing that success is driving a $15,000 Toyota … that you own outright.
Tread Your Own Path!
The $32,000 Couch
Hi Scott, Ten years ago I got a ‘buy now, pay later’ $4,000 ‘living room package’ at a retailer (couch, TV, coffee table). Actually, the deal was that they gave me a GEM Visa with a $6,000 limit … so another $2,000 credit, which I stupidly spent.
Hi Scott,
Ten years ago I got a ‘buy now, pay later’ $4,000 ‘living room package’ at a retailer (couch, TV, coffee table). Actually, the deal was that they gave me a GEM Visa with a $6,000 limit … so another $2,000 credit, which I stupidly spent. Fast forward 10 years and I am still struggling to pay it back. I am a single mother with a chronic illness, and while I really want to work I just haven’t been able to. Yet so far I have paid back $32,000. Last year, while I was in hospital, my debt was sold to another group, Lion Finance. They arranged a $10-a-week payment plan, but my debt has increased by $1,000 in the last year. I need your help!
Lisa
Hi Lisa,
Your email makes me sad, and incredibly mad. (So today I’m going to be a little bad.)
What a bunch of … bankers.
The business model of these institutions is basically to take advantage of people like you who don’t understand the complex contracts they’ve signed up to.
Yet you have acted honourably: you made a 15-minute mistake and have steadfastly paid a huge price for 10 years because of it.
Now you’re probably thinking to yourself, “Well, I’m just a single mum on a disability benefit, there’s nothing I can do … these finance guys have the upper hand”.
No, they don’t.You have the upper hand.
Together, we’re going to get this debt wiped -- to zero.
Don’t get me wrong. Generally, I’m in favour of people paying back their debts, but you’re in a special situation:
First, you’ve repaid the principal plus more than your fair share of interest over the past decade.
Second, the Lion Finance deal is disgusting: you’re repaying $520 a year, yet your debt rises by $1,000! On a Centrelink income, you’ll never, ever, clear it. They’ve effectively trapped you for the rest of your life.
And, finally, what are they going to do if you stop paying?
Well, they’ll probably huff, and puff, and threaten to blow your house down. But the truth is they can’t do anything: you don’t have any capacity to repay the debt, and you have no assets.
So this week I want you to call the National Debt Helpline on 1800 007 007 and ask to speak to a financial counsellor. Tell them your story, email them the paperwork, and request a debt waiver.
Time to stand up to the bullies.
Scott
From Zero to Five Kids
Hi Scott, My wife and I — who have had an ongoing struggle with infertility — foster three children. And it has been awesome.
Hi Scott,
My wife and I — who have had an ongoing struggle with infertility — foster three children. And it has been awesome. However, we have just been given news that has floored us. Last week our doctor called to say we’re pregnant … with twins! Having just picked myself up off the floor, I am trying to figure out how to fast-track our savings to raise five kids. You have helped us wipe out $55,000 worth of debt and save $40,000 for a deposit thus far. We would appreciate any extra advice you can give us now.
John
Hi John,
Now there’s a plot twist I didn’t see coming. I have three children under the age of six, and the most common greeting I get from people is “You look tired”. But you two have gone from a comfy Kia to Toyota Tarago territory in just one phone call!
If we’re looking ‘glass half full’, remember that you’ve already paid off $55,000 in debt and saved up a solid deposit in the bank.
Yet the truth is that one of you will have to take time off work, and, with twins, probably for quite a while.
My advice?
Well, I wouldn’t be rushing to buy a house anytime soon. Instead, the money you’ve saved up should stand as your financial buffer, at least until you’ve worked out the lay of the land. The last thing you need right now is mortgage stress. You’re already going to have sleepless nights — no need to add to them.
Scott
I Spent $2,000 on Powerball Last Night
Hi Scott, I spent $2,000 on Powerball last night and apparently did not even win my tickets back. I feel pathetic.
Hi Scott,
I spent $2,000 on Powerball last night and apparently did not even win my tickets back. I feel pathetic.
On my way to work this morning, I began to listen to your book (for the second time) on Audible and decided to write to you — and be honest with you (and myself). My husband and I are both 33. Not young, not old. We have three home loans and a car loan, and plan to have a baby soon. I also have a hard copy of your book on my desk and feel I am on my way to financial freedom, but it seems a long way to go.
Bridget
Hi Bridget,
I’ve answered thousands of questions, but I have never had someone tell me they spent two grand on a lottery.
Powerball? Is that even still a thing? I remember it looking like some tricked-up vacuum-cleaner spitting out coloured balls. The odds of winning Division 1 Powerball (according to their own website) are 134 million to 1.Here’s you: “Yeah, but you gotta be in it to win it, right?”
Here’s me: “Yeah, but if you think that way, make sure you steer clear of vending machines.”
(Statistically, you’re more likely to be killed by a vending machine falling on you — 112 million to 1.)
Okay, enough of the gags: there’s something deeper going on here.
You’re either an addicted gambler, in which case you should get professional help, because it’s an illness that won’t go away untreated (call Gamblers Help on 1800 858 858), or you’ve got a feeling of hopelessness about your situation.
Either way, there are no shortcuts to anywhere worth going.
Yet know this: you don’t have to hit the jackpot to feel good about yourself or your financial situation.
Instead, when you see a path out of despair (and hopefully my book can help you with this), each step you take will build your confidence.
From there, it’s just a matter of time: you’re already free.
Scott
My Girlfriend Was Hiding a Secret from Me
Hello Mr Barefoot, Just finished your book and it has completely changed my perspective on money — I finally believe I will be able to buy my future home in Sydney. That was until my girlfriend of one year surprised me with her $30,000 debt (credit cards, personal loan and education fees).
Hello Mr Barefoot,
Just finished your book and it has completely changed my perspective on money — I finally believe I will be able to buy my future home in Sydney. That was until my girlfriend of one year surprised me with her $30,000 debt (credit cards, personal loan and education fees). I had a grand plan of saving together and buying a home, but now I feel like someone has stolen my mojo. How do I attack this problem?
Chris
Hi Chris,
She deserves your respect: it would have taken a lot of courage for her to lay bare her true financial state.
Honestly, the number of people who don’t do this till after they’re engaged — or married — is astounding.
Explain to her how you feel, and that you’ll work together to help her get on top of her finances.
You won’t do this by giving her money — this isn’t your problem — rather, you’ll support her by loaning her a copy of my book, and reinforcing good money behaviours by going on lots of saucy Barefoot date nights.
By the end of the year you’ll have a good idea of how committed she is to fixing her finances. If she sorts herself out, it’ll be a source of strength in your relationship. If she can’t, well, at least you know what you’re in for.
Scott
I Vowed to Write to You Once We Were Debt Free
Dear Scott, Ten years ago, my wife and I were drowning in debt, with a big mortgage and maxed-out credit cards. I came across a copy of your (first) Barefoot Investor book and vowed to change our circumstances and write to you once we were debt free.
Dear Scott,
Ten years ago, my wife and I were drowning in debt, with a big mortgage and maxed-out credit cards. I came across a copy of your (first) Barefoot Investor book and vowed to change our circumstances and write to you once we were debt free. Well, this week, 10 years on, in our early 40s, we paid the final instalment on our home loan. We have also built a healthy share portfolio and have not used a credit card in 10 years. It is the most amazing feeling to get there. We are debt free, and we sincerely thank you.
Dom
That has made my week.
But let me tell you: it has nothing to do with me (well, apart from a little at the start).
It’s you who did it, internalised it, lived it. You are freaking amazing.
Most people don’t stick to anything, ever. The fact that you were able to do this for 10 years … that’s incredible.
You pulled yourself out of a pit for 10 years!
Now, here is my prediction: if you can stick to something for 10 long years, the next 10 years are going to be really exciting for you. Because, if you continue doing what you’re doing, you’re going to build serious wealth for yourselves (rather than the bank).
With the dedication you’ve shown, I want you to email me in another 10 years’ time and tell me you’re millionaires. You deserve all the success in the world. I’m really proud of you.
Scott
My Baby Sent Me Broke
Hi Scott, Over the last two-and-a-half years we have had two babies and a wedding. Our first baby came earlier than planned so it wasn’t covered by private health, and we made the silly choice to pay for it out of pocket.
Hi Scott,
Over the last two-and-a-half years we have had two babies and a wedding. Our first baby came earlier than planned so it wasn’t covered by private health, and we made the silly choice to pay for it out of pocket. Then, over a couple of years on one income ($240,000), we have accumulated two credit card bills totalling a hefty $60,000. We have now read your book and managed to pay off two large loans using your method, but we do not know how to get these credit cards paid off. Please help!
Katie
Katie,
Look, I’m all for blaming my kids for everything (especially on a Sunday morning), but $60,000?
Seriously?
The cost of having a kid in a private hospital, assuming no complications, is about $10k.
Other parents have weddings and babies, but they don’t have $60k on the never-never.
You’re earning $13k a month in the hand, but you’re broke.
Why?
Because you’re spending too much.
If you’re looking for a magic wand, you can go to MyBudget (see above).
But if you ask me, you’ve already proved to yourself twice that you can pay down debt, so three times is a charm.
Besides, you guys are high income earners ‒ you could have this debt paid off within the year.
Even better, you’ll set a great example for your kids.
Scott
I Owe MyBudget $1,250
Hey Barefoot, I signed up with a money managing agency MyBudget because I felt that some financial structure and discipline would be good, and also to make my parents happy. Unfortunately, the model did not work for me.
Hey Barefoot,
I signed up with a money managing agency MyBudget because I felt that some financial structure and discipline would be good, and also to make my parents happy. Unfortunately, the model did not work for me. I do not think it is okay for someone with mental health issues to be told they cannot see their psychologist because there is no money for it, or they cannot have their prescriptions filled at the chemist for the same reason.
At the time, I signed a contract for 12 months but I found it far too restrictive and inflexible, and started managing my money myself again after only a few months. The trouble is, I ended up owing MyBudget approx $1,250 in fees and charges.I was asked to pay within a timeframe but I never did, as I couldn’t afford it. Now I am following the Barefoot steps, I don’t think I can say I am truly debt free and don’t owe a cent to anyone until I clear this. So I would like your advice as to what to do ‒ pay up, or assume that MyBudget have written off the debt?
Tara
Hi Tara
I wouldn’t pay them.
Then again, I don’t think anyone should pay them.
First, because they’ve built their business on the back of broke, vulnerable people.
(For those who don’t know, MyBudget is the financial equivalent of having a personal trainer come around, lock your fridge and dish out the food to you.)
Second, because they charge too bloody much.
(Over a thousand dollars upfront, as well as ongoing fees.)
Quick quiz: if MyBudget are running your budget, guess who gets paid first?
If you answered “my psychologist”, or maybe “the chemist for my prescribed medicine”, you would be wrong.
Third, because no one should hand over the responsibility of managing their money.
Seriously, if what you’re saying is true ‒ that their budgeting person said you should scrimp on mental health and prescriptions ‒ that’s kind of … crazy.
So I’d write a letter to them explaining your issues and saying that you got awful service, and because of that you’d like them to write off the debt (and provide you with a letter confirming they’ve done it).
And if they say no, I’ll take it up on your behalf.
Note to readers: if you’re having problems with debt, you should ring 1800 007 007 and speak to a community-based financial counsellor. They offer an independent service, and best of all they don’t charge $1,250 … they do it for free.
Scott
I am FURIOUS
Hi Scott, I am FURIOUS. I study full time (business at UTS) and work round the clock in real estate to support myself, while all my uni friends bludge off the Government.
Hi Scott,
I am FURIOUS.I study full time (business at UTS) and work round the clock in real estate to support myself, while all my uni friends bludge off the Government. Last year I earned $48,000, and to my absolute disgust my accountant tells me I’ll be up for HECS even though I am still studying! This is wrong on so many levels. You should do something about this.
Sarah
Hi Sarah,
As Tony Jones says on Q&A, “I’ll take that as a comment”.
What old stubby-fingers your accountant was telling you is true. The Government has reduced the amount you need to earn to start repaying your HECS debt to $45,881, regardless of whether you are still studying.
Is that unfair?
I don’t think so. Your HECS debt is effectively an interest-free loan, tied to the general rate of inflation. So it’s a lot better than the massive student debts that burden students in America.
My advice?
Don’t be furious, and quit comparing yourself to your friends: it’s a recipe for unhappiness.
Besides, paying tax is a good thing: it means you’re earning money. And the more money you make, the quicker you’ll get rid of your HECS debt!
Scott
Fighting in the Jungle
Hey Scott, My mother and her partner owe money left, right and centre -- in fact the sheriff is chasing them for more than $100,000. But they live in a caravan and are ‘on the run’ (not so much Bonnie and Clyde, more like postcard bandits).
Hey Scott,
My mother and her partner owe money left, right and centre -- in fact the sheriff is chasing them for more than $100,000. But they live in a caravan and are ‘on the run’ (not so much Bonnie and Clyde, more like postcard bandits). So both my brother and I are having the sheriff roll up at our houses looking for them. And we regularly receive letters from banks looking for them. What can we do to fix this situation?
Fiona
Hi Fiona,
I see your postcard bandit analogy, and I’ll raise you.
They remind me of Hiroo Onoda.
Hiroo who?
He was a Japanese soldier in World War Two, stationed in a jungle in the Philippines.
Unfortunately, no-one told him the war was over, so he spent 29 years in the jungle believing it was still going.
In the same way, your mum and her partner still believe they’re fighting a financial war against their creditors.
The reality is that if they’ve got a sheriff chasing them they’ve already had a court judgement against them.In other words: the war is over, and they are the casualties.
The creditor has 15 years to chase them for the debt (well, in Victoria, other states differ). And during that time the creditor can enforce the debt by seizing their goods, garnishing their wages, or forcing them into bankruptcy.
So what can they do?
Well, they can pay the debt off in full (though that’s unlikely), negotiate to pay the debt off in instalments, or raise the white (financial) flag.
Regardless, the sooner they can call in the cavalry -- in the form of their local community-based financial counsellor (1800 007 007) -- the better.
Scott
And the Judge’s Gavel Fell
Scott, I have a court judgment against me for a $10,000 credit card debt, along with other credit card and personal loan debts that have accumulated to over $20,000. Over the last three years I have recovered from addiction and mental health issues, as well as homelessness.
Scott,
I have a court judgment against me for a $10,000 credit card debt, along with other credit card and personal loan debts that have accumulated to over $20,000. Over the last three years I have recovered from addiction and mental health issues, as well as homelessness. Through hard work I have finally landed myself a stable job in the industry I studied at uni for, earning $96,500 a year. Still I cannot get ahead. I would like to go bankrupt to wipe the slate clean and start again. Is this a good idea?
Natalie
Hi Natalie
Rising strong!
Congratulations on your continued recovery. That shows courage and perseverance. You’re a fighter.
Yet bankruptcy, in my opinion, is not an option ‒ you’re earning too much dough!So what should you do instead?
First things first, get a copy of your credit file and see what’s on it.
Then, you have a couple of options:
You could contact your lenders (specifically, their hardship departments) and disclose that you took out the debt when you were suffering from addiction, mental health issues and homelessness. If you can provide supporting documentation from doctors and case study workers, you may be able to have the debt waived on hardship and compassionate grounds (and there may also be ways to have the $10,000 court judgement waived as well).
Or you could choose to negotiate a realistic repayment schedule. On your income you’d pay if off inside of a year.
You Got This!
Scott